In honour of the phrase being soon to be emblazoned on the front of the winners t-shirt, and well, because the book is out in paperback, we present to you, Egg Plant Totally Skill fans, the full, unedited extended cake metaphor as featured in Gilesy's rather fetching read 'The Great & The Good'. And it will save us having to always try and remember wherabouts in the book it is when we want to have a chuckle.
In this passage, Gilsey is talking about Rodney Marsh signing for Man Cityin 1972 when he gets a tad distracted, but he manages to go full circle by the end. Prepare yourselves........
" Marsh was signed for £200,000, supposedly as the icing on the cake. Unfortunately, that particular cake collapsed, and City ended up in fourth that season.
Not that the idea of the icing on the cake is always a bad one. But it can get a bit complicated."
(Indeed it can, John!).....deep breath.........
"At Tottenham you could say that Jimmy Graves was the icing on the cake, but Dave Mackay was the cake.
At Leeds in my time, Allan Clarke was the icing on the cake when he arrived from Leicester City. At Liverpool, you couldn't really say that vital signings such as Kevin Keegan or Kenny Dalglish were the icing on the cake - they were probably a bit of both.
But when Alex Ferguson signed Eric Cantona, he was all icing, Roy Keane was the cake. And Keane would have been the cake in any other team, but Cantona would not necessarily have been the icing in another team.
George best was probably the icing - but very good icing - on a cake made by Bobby Charlton and Nobby Stiles. At Arsenal, Dennis Bergkamp was the icing on a Bruce Rioch cake - but it was a pretty dull cake.
Some say that Marco van Basten, Ruud Gullit and Frank Rijkaard were the icing on the cake made by Paolo Maldini and Franco Baresi for AC Milan, though in fact they all helped to make that particular cake.
Real players, on the whole, tend to be part icing, part cake. And yet players who are all icing, like Cantona, can be just what a team needs and they can play a huge part in the team's success - especially if they are finishers.
Sadly the icing that was Rodney Marsh on the cake that was Manchester City was never going to be a success."
Genius.
Words cannot describe how much I love that piece of literature. I can only assume John's editor was so in awe of him, he couldn't bear to tell him he may have gone just a wee bit too far with his cake metaphor. Class.
ReplyDeleteAs I was writing this out, the thought did cross my mind that maybe John was taking the piss. But...no....I don't think he is.
ReplyDelete